Airbnb Strengthens Security Measures: Balancing Safety and Host Autonomy

Thibault Masson

Airbnb, the popular online vacation rental platform, recently announced a series of changes to enhance safety and trust within its community. While these changes are primarily focused on ensuring a secure environment for guests, some hosts have expressed concerns about the growing level of control exerted by Airbnb, which they believe can make their hosting experience more challenging.

Comprehensive Identity Verification Process

By the end of June 2023, Airbnb has mandated that 100 percent of guests booking homes and primary hosts globally undergo the comprehensive identity verification process. This process aims to enhance trust and credibility within the Airbnb community. While hosts generally agree that guest safety is paramount, some feel that the increased control imposed by Airbnb can make it more difficult for them to manage their listings effectively.

Hosts now face the task of guiding guests through the verification process, ensuring compliance, and potentially facing limitations on accepting bookings if they themselves haven’t completed the verification. This additional layer of scrutiny, although well-intentioned, has left some hosts feeling encumbered by the requirements imposed by Airbnb.

Changes to Guest Email Aliases

In a recent announcement, Airbnb revealed that starting from September 30, 2023, guests’ email aliases, previously used to protect their privacy during communication with hosts, will no longer be shared. This decision stems from Airbnb’s desire to centralize messaging within its platform and restrict communication to the Airbnb Messaging product and its inbox.

While guest privacy remains important, hosts are concerned that this change may hinder effective communication and personalization, potentially impacting their ability to provide a tailored and hospitable experience.

Airbnb’s Quality Initiative

As part of its ongoing commitment to upholding high standards, Airbnb has taken a more targeted and holistic approach to quality enforcement. This approach has already resulted in the removal of over 12,000 listings globally since April 2023. In 2022 alone, an estimated 81,000 listings were removed globally for failing to meet Airbnb’s standards regarding host reliability and quality.

While hosts agree that maintaining quality is crucial, some feel that the increasingly stringent policies and the high number of listing removals may be disproportionately punitive, potentially penalizing hosts for minor issues beyond their control.

Finding a Balance: Safety and Control

While hosts understand the importance of ensuring guest safety and fostering trust, there is a prevailing sentiment that Airbnb’s measures have veered toward excessive control. Hosts argue that the platform’s focus on security sometimes comes at the expense of their autonomy and the flexibility needed to provide a unique and personalized hosting experience.

Hosts are eager to collaborate with Airbnb to find a middle ground that ensures guest safety while allowing them the freedom to manage their listings efficiently. They emphasize the need for open dialogue, where their concerns are heard and considered in shaping future policies and procedures.


As Airbnb tightens its control over hosts to enhance safety and credibility, concerns have arisen among some hosts about the impact on their hosting experience. While guest safety remains a top priority, Airbnb must strike a balance between security measures and preserving the autonomy of hosts. By fostering ongoing communication and collaboration with hosts, Airbnb can address their concerns and work together to create a secure and supportive environment that benefits both guests and hosts alike.

Get the most important short-term rental news and insights straight to your inbox, for FREE.

Subscribe to our newsletter using the form below.