VAT Directive’s Looming Threat: Small European Short-Term Rental Players in Peril

Uvika Wahi

VAT Shake-up in European Short-Term Rentals: Small Players at Risk?

Do you know that from January 2025, your guests may have to pay up to 25% more on every booking? Brace yourselves for the impending storm of EU laws that could redefine the European short-term rental industry.

Big booking platforms like Booking.com and Airbnb are set to automatically charge VAT for every booking in the European Union, regardless of whether you’re an occasional host or a professional manager. This transformation stems from the “VAT in the Digital Age” (ViDA) proposal, an amendment to the European VAT directive that promises to reshape the sector’s dynamics. Yet, there’s more to the story; every short-term rental operator across the EU will soon need a registration number, thanks to the impending EU regulation on short-term rental data collection and sharing.

Intrigued? You should be. We’ve delved into the heart of these groundbreaking developments with Viktorija Molnar, Acting Secretary General of the European Holiday Home Association (EHHA). Her insights cast a spotlight on the potential consequences of these legislative juggernauts for the unsung heroes of the short-term rental world – the smaller players who have always been the lifeblood of this dynamic industry.

Stay with us as we explore the immediate challenges that these laws pose, honing in on the survival of small-scale short-term rental operators. Viktorija Molnar and other industry insiders have raised critical concerns that we’ll be unraveling. Together, we’ll shed light on the delicate balance between VAT requirements and the very existence of these vital players. The future of European short-term rentals is at stake, and the answers lie ahead in this captivating journey through evolving legislation and its real-world implications.

The Voice of Insight: Viktorija Molnar and the European Holiday Home Association

Meet Viktorija Molnar, the Acting Secretary General of the European Holiday Home Association (EHHA). At the heart of Brussels, the EU’s nerve center, EHHA stands as a united force advocating for the interests of short-term rental accommodation players throughout the continent.

EHHA’s significance transcends its role as a mere observer; it’s an active participant in shaping the laws that influence the short-term rental domain. With her watchful eye on EU legislative proceedings, Molnar scrutinizes drafts for their potential impact on the industry. EHHA’s role doesn’t stop at observation; its insights and perspectives contribute to the EU’s decision-making process.

Directive vs. Regulation: How the Fine Print Defines Implementation

As the European short-term rental industry braces for transformative changes, a pivotal distinction emerges – the difference between a directive and a regulation. This contrast isn’t just legalese; it’s the roadmap that determines how impending EU laws will take shape.

Directive: Defining Goals, Delegating Paths

When a directive comes into play, the European Union outlines a goal to be achieved, leaving member states to navigate their unique paths to that destination. Viktorija Molnar, Acting Secretary General of the European Holiday Home Association, elucidates, “Directive means that EU is sort of setting some sort of goal, what has to be achieved, but the form and how it has to be achieved, it is left to member states.” This leaves room for tailored approaches, with each nation crafting its own strategies to meet the overarching objective.

Regulation: The Universal Mandate

On the other hand, a regulation paints with broader strokes. Molnar lays it out, “If regulation is adopted at EU level, it means that this legislative act will be directly applied in all member states. So member states, they do not have to make any additional laws. It is already there and they have to comply with it.” A regulation is a pan-European directive, eliminating the need for further national legislation – a universal code of conduct that applies across the EU.

The implications of this difference resonate profoundly as we navigate the “VAT in the Digital Age” (ViDA) proposal and the “EU regulation on short rental data collection and sharing.” The former, a directive, empowers member states to chart their courses within the framework set by the EU. The latter, a regulation, ushers in universal changes without the need for individual adaptations. 

The VAT Directive Unveiled: Threat to Smaller Players?

At the heart of the impending changes lies the VAT directive – a substantial overhaul with far-reaching implications. Let’s dissect the essence of this directive and uncover its potential impact on short-term rental businesses:

1. Expanding VAT Scope:

The proposed VAT directive extends its reach to encompass a wider range of short-term rental operators, including private individuals and SMEs. This marks a departure from the traditional VAT exemption these entities enjoyed.

2. VAT Charge on Top of Booking Price:

Under the directive, booking platforms like Airbnb and Booking.com will automatically charge VAT on every booking, regardless of the host’s status. This could result in price hikes for guests.

3. Equal Treatment for Hotels and Short-Term Rentals:

Hotels, which traditionally charged VAT on overnight stays, had the advantage of deducting input VAT. The directive now brings short-term rentals into a similar tax regime, blurring the lines between these accommodation options.

4. Disadvantages for Small Players:

Private individuals and SMEs may find themselves at a disadvantage due to their inability to deduct input VAT. This could lead to higher costs for short-term rental operators with limited financial resources.

5. Transforming Small Players into Professionals:

The VAT directive pushes smaller players into a more professional realm, with VAT obligations similar to established businesses. This transition could reshape the landscape, with implications for competitiveness and pricing strategies.

6. Impact on Consumer Pricing:

As VAT becomes an integral part of the booking process, consumer prices may surge. This could undermine the affordability of short-term rentals compared to hotels, which can offset VAT through deductions.

7. Administrative Complexities:

Navigating VAT requirements can introduce administrative complexities, particularly for individuals and SMEs unaccustomed to such obligations. Compliance might demand additional resources and time.

8. Uneven Competition:

The VAT directive has the potential to alter the competitive dynamics within the hospitality sector. Hotels, with their VAT deductions, might gain a pricing edge over small short-term rental players.

EU Regulation on Short Rental Data Collection and Sharing: A New Era Unfolds

Continuing our exploration of the transformative EU landscape, we revisit a proposal we’ve previously touched upon: the EU regulation on short rental data collection and sharing. This forthcoming regulation is poised to redefine the way the short-term rental sector operates, with a focus on data transparency and streamlined processes. Here’s a closer look at what lies ahead:

1. Addressing Data Void:

In response to the persistent lack of comprehensive data on short-term rentals, the EU recognized the need for transparency and information sharing. This recognition led to the formulation of a robust regulatory framework.

2. Framework Essence:

EU member states are gearing up to establish online registration procedures for short-term rental hosts. This process will involve collecting key non-static details such as names, addresses, and contact numbers.

3. Simplified Registration:

Hosts, both occasional and professional, will navigate a user-friendly online registration procedure. This will result in the issuance of a registration number, a pivotal piece of identification.

4. Platform Partnership:

Once hosts acquire their registration number, they will be required to prominently display it within their online rental listings. In parallel, online booking platforms like Airbnb and Booking.com will play a crucial role.

5. Unified Data Ecosystem:

The envisioned system amalgamates non-static host data with activity data gleaned from platforms. This unified dataset will equip authorities with a comprehensive view of the short-term rental landscape.

6. Envisioned Impact:

The holistic data perspective holds the potential to inform regulatory decisions at local and national levels. The ultimate goal is to shape proportionate and fair short-term rental regulations, benefitting all stakeholders.

7. Overcoming Hurdles:

As with any transformative shift, challenges emerge. The proposed regulation aims to overcome these hurdles through an innovative approach. Viktorija Molnar highlighted that the burden of data sharing will be split between stakeholders. This novel approach alleviates friction between governments and platforms while safeguarding data privacy.

8. The Road Ahead:

While the regulation is not yet in effect, the wheels of progress are turning. The European Parliament and Council representatives are actively shaping the final text, with a goal to adopt the regulation by the end of the year.

Hosts and Managers Unite: How You Can Forge the Future of Short-Term Rentals

As regulations like the VAT directive and the EU regulation on short rental data collection and sharing materialize, the voices of those on the frontline become critical. Here’s how hosts and managers can actively participate in shaping the future of the short-term rental industry:

1. Awareness and Education:

 Stay informed about proposed regulations and their implications. Engage in research and discussions to grasp the nuances of each proposal.

2. Join Industry Associations:

Organizations like the European Holiday Home Association (EHHA) act as collective voices for the short-term rental community. Becoming a member aligns you with a platform to voice concerns and advocate for balanced legislation.

3. Participate in Public Consultations:

Many EU proposals solicit public opinions during their drafting stages. Seize the opportunity to submit your thoughts, experiences, and concerns directly to policymakers.

4. Attend Workshops and Conferences:

Industry events offer networking and learning opportunities. Participate in discussions, workshops, and panels focused on regulatory changes, sharing your insights and experiences.

5. Collaborate with Peers:

Connect with fellow hosts, property managers, and industry professionals. Share knowledge, experiences, and ideas to collectively amplify your impact.

6. Communicate with Platforms:

Engage with online booking platforms where you list your properties. Provide feedback on the proposed changes and their potential impact on your business.

7. Engage with Local Authorities:

Your perspective matters to local governments. Engage in conversations with municipal authorities, sharing insights on how regulations affect your operations.

8. Advocate for Fairness:

Champion regulations that strike a balance between consumer protection, taxation, and the sustainability of small players. Highlight the potential impacts on competition and pricing.

9. Amplify Your Voice Online:

Leverage social media platforms, forums, and blogs to share your perspective. Engage in respectful dialogues with stakeholders and policymakers.

10. Stay Adaptable:

Regulatory landscapes evolve. Be prepared to adapt your business practices to meet new standards while advocating for practical, effective, and equitable regulations.

As the wheels of change turn, your active involvement can wield profound influence. By participating in discussions, sharing insights, and advocating for fair regulations, hosts and managers can play a pivotal role in shaping the trajectory of the short-term rental industry. As the industry navigates uncharted waters, your voice becomes a beacon of balance and fairness in the evolving legislative landscape.

Get the most important short-term rental news and insights straight to your inbox, for FREE.

Subscribe to our newsletter using the form below.